Across Syria & Inside Homs

Wednesday, March 29, 2006

Syrian Politics for Dummies

Farhan the fool, has suggested that those who want to understand the politics of Syria should read These exerts from Syria's embassador in Washington, Dr. Imad Mustapha speach at the World Affairs Council in San Francisco, this past December, and those from Soner Caqabtay, director of Turkey Research Program at the Washington Institute for Near East Policies, artlicle:"Republic of Caution".
Farhan, claims that after you finish reading, it is a no brainer, the earth is after all flat.

Imad Mustapha:

“I am not claiming today that Syria today is a full fledged Democracy, but please do remember that democracy is unattainable Ideal in which people or nations move towards”

“Today in Syria we have a one party system, but it is not a one party system full stop. We have made a strategic decision. It has already been taken and it will be implemented in the near future…six months ago, the ruling party of Syria, the bath party, made a decision that it will allow a multiparty system in Syria as from right now, and a new law, a draft law is already been circulating in Damascus allowing the free formation of political parties in Syria. And this is the first necessary step allowing multiparty elections,

“Most spectators would say that if free elections take place today in Syria, the most probable outcome would be that fundamentalists groups will win the majorities in elections, it does not mean that because this is the case then we should not move towards democracy, what we want to do is revitalize the civil society in Syria. And I could tell you that at least in the past two or three years the margin of civil liberties has expanded considerably in Syria, and if you read sometimes that Syria is a rouge state, police, or authoritarian state. I would say to you don’t believe it, I am not saying that Syria is a democracy today, I am saying that the political system in Syria is opening up and inviting for more and more political participation by the political spectrum in Syria."

“The new law that would allow for the formation of political parties in Syria is 180 degrees different from the electoral law in Iraq....We said, no party can be formed in Syria, unless it is a party of national agenda, not ethnic or religious agenda”

“Please do remember that Syria has a good record on women empowerment, for the past 50 years, since independence women enjoyed equal rights to men in Syria… also Syria enjoys unparallel religious freedom….”

Soner Cagaptay :

"The Baath regime in Syria is no longer about socialism or Arab nationalism of the 1970s. Rather, this is a regime interested in maintaining its monopoly of Syria's wealth through a network of intertwined military and economic posts. Corruption is the largest sector of the Syrian economy, ahead of industry and tourism," explained one Western diplomat whom I met in Damascus"

"In Aleppo, the country's second largest city, I was told that the town's previous mayor owned eight brand new Mercedes cars, despite earning an official salary of $500 per month."

"Across the country, I heard similar stories. Syria is not quite a republic of fear, where people are afraid to talk about the government...Syrians freely criticize the Baath regime on issues ranging from corruption to the failure to deliver prosperity"
"A waiter at a small roadside restaurant near Homs, a conservative Sunni Arab city, testified to this fact. He said that Syria's intelligence apparatus, the mukhabbarat, has pulled out of the streets. "Accordingly, people feel free to talk about the regime in ways not possible a few years ago," he said, but then hedged his statement. "We know the mukhabbarat has only taken one step back. In other words, if we were to act, they would quickly come back to crush any opposition."

"Hence, even if the Syrians are no longer afraid of the Baath party, they are, nevertheless, cautious."

"the Baath regime is preventing liberal intellectuals from channeling popular discontent into organized dissent. Independent thinkers are harassed and intimated on a daily basis. I was told by a diplomat that outspoken liberals are jailed if they develop a habit of meeting Westerners.
With no access to the government-run media, liberals are unable to reach out to the Syrian people. Accordingly, they are unknown outside of the intellectual and expatriate circles of Damascus.

"With liberals in jail and the notable families out of politics, Islamists are flourishing, using existing networks, such as mosques and charities, to appeal to people who are fed up with the Baath regime. The Muslim Brotherhood's rhetoric of "clean religious government" is attracting many supporters, particularly in desert towns such as Deir-Zor, and the Sunni heartland.

"Supporters of democracy in Syria are between a rock and a hard place. On the one hand, the regime is oppressing them; on the other hand, the Islamists are growing because they are able to avoid the government's steel claw from the security of their mosques and charities. So long as the regime refuses to make political room for the liberals and the notables, the discontent of the Syrian people will continue to energize the Islamist movements.

"If there were free elections in Syria, the Baath would not get more than 10 percent of the vote," said a cab driver in Aleppo. If things stay as they are, the Baath might as well deliver Syria on a silver tray to the Islamists. "To us, Islamists are lesser of the two evils. Better them than the West," said a senior Baath official in Damascus.
Note:
the Washington Institute for Near East Policies, is the most prominant jewish funded think-tank in washington D.C.
On the other hand, Dr. Imad Mustapha represent the view of of the Syrian goverment.

13 Comments:

  • Dear Amr,
    Thank you so much for this post. You have released my tension from this man who claims to be a nice smiling civilized representative to Syrian people. When he is in reality a representative to the government who until know have no respect to its citizens inside or outside the country. It is a system started 40-50 years ago, every one of us knows that when we process papers or ask for services from them inside or outside the country, we do not get the service without delay, bad treatment, and sometimes paying under the table. I will challenge him to tell us how much they are paying the poor small employee in the embassy (who usually have two other jobs and working as a Mokhabarat) how much they pay him so he can perform and be respected human being so he can respect others. Mr. civilized who is trying to run after Syrian intellectuals and associate with them cannot ignore the fact that we do not feel him as a representative. how much he tries to do good and advertise for artists and authors. Get real Man who you are fooling, may be yourself.

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 3/30/2006 4:59 AM  

  • Amr,

    Just read your post after watching a videotape of Bashar's interview with Charlie Rose. My brain is numb. You are wrong! the world is not flat, it is a cube!

    I agree with Anonymous that Imad Mustapha is an apologist for this brutal regime hiding behind a civilized veneer. I don't understand people like him. Do they really believe what they saying? I guess in self deception, after repeating a lie often enough it starts to look like the truth.

    By Blogger Abu Kareem, at 3/30/2006 1:59 PM  

  • Very well said.
    They monopolize and slaughter history. and we always wait for the wave to pass...

    By Blogger Ghassan, at 3/31/2006 8:08 AM  

  • I can not believe he has a blog! And it looks like his life is a vacation! This is our ambassedor to the US people!

    By Blogger Hattori Hanzo, at 4/02/2006 7:34 AM  

  • the world is a cube indeed :) that's funny.
    abu kareem i wouldn't say self deception and i'm sure they don't believe it, they're just master liers. it's the patronizing policy that has been prevalent in lebanon and syria and the US. it is shocking to hear these allegations. who really does believe it and who is he trying to fool by 'Syrians freely criticize the Baath regime'!!!!.
    also it's true, they try to divert the people's attention to small internal issues like corruption where the real issue is correct representation and having more than one party to control the whole country.
    i think the situation in lebanon is very nicely parallel to that in syria, which in my opinion will be the fate of the arab nations put together. also in lebanon, it's the baath ruling still versus the west. we need to be careful about a question:
    is the west (usa) really interested in occupying us at the moment. very unlikely with the upcoming 2008 elections and the economical situation
    also without or with the baath, when america wants to rule, they will.
    so i say forget about the threat of the west for now. they hve too much problems going on here anyway. and seek a healthy representation in the country. then the west won't have an excuse to strike (since bush would love that) based on the lack of democracy like he did in iraq.

    that all is of course in an ideal world (around one) but the world is a cube!

    By Blogger Mirvat, at 4/05/2006 10:32 AM  

  • If the ambassador is reading these comments on this blogpost, I would like to give him a challenge: Make the embassy web site as good as your blogpost?. Improve the forms and make it look official and on the level of a respected country (like adding stamp,…). Ask for an increase in your salary and the employees’ salaries so they would be respected and in turn they would respect others.
    As far as I know from my experience in other countries, our ambssadors usually do not have good salaries and so they trade with prohibited subjects.

    By Blogger quest trust, at 4/05/2006 4:24 PM  

  • Hattori,

    I see nothing wrong with Mr. Mustapha having his blog.

    All,

    Thank you for your comments

    By Blogger Amr T, at 4/05/2006 6:35 PM  

  • Amr, you are right, there is nothing wrong with Mr. Mustapha having his own blog. What I have against it is that his picture makes it look very offcial, while he discusses art and family trips and picnics.

    Not to mention that, at this time, he should be busy trying to get our word across and mending relations with the western world, and not posting such things.

    In addition, I am sure that there is alot to be improved about the syrian embassy. I have never dealt with this particular one, but I have dealt with other syrian embassies in the world, and it is not fun. I am sure this one is no different from what i hear from friends. Why doesn't he spend some time improving that?

    By Blogger Hattori Hanzo, at 4/05/2006 10:16 PM  

  • I think again we are falling down in the trap of ‘stereotype issue’ I think the main goal of this article was to show 2 different points of view about a situation and not about an individual.., actually these points of view are not different ,,our ambassador is more ‘polite ‘ in addressing the issue ..That’s all…but at least he is considering it..i always admired his blog,being a personal activity ,which –I think- a positive point in his characheter.
    As I knew he is one of the most educated, liberal,and wise men that can move carefully and ‘politely ‘ for a man in his position. I again confirm that this article is not to be a criticism for any individual….
    Other comments that we received need no further clarifications

    By Blogger Haider Droubi, at 4/06/2006 3:54 AM  

  • Great site lots of usefull infomation here.
    »

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 5/16/2006 12:24 PM  

  • Greets to the webmaster of this wonderful site. Keep working. Thank you.
    »

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 5/16/2006 12:36 PM  

  • Dr.Imad Mustapha's opening remark that "Democracy is an unattainable ideal in which people or nations move towards" is linguistically obscure, to say the least.
    However one cannot disagree with his statement that the Regime "is not a One-Party System - full stop". Indeed, it is a No-Party system, at all. It is a Far-West
    dictatorship by a Minority Clan whose only aim is to hang-on to Power at all costs and plunder the country as long as the going is good, terrorizing the citizenry
    with their Minority Mokhabarat, which shld instead be doing its Intelligence work on Israel...But despite all appearances and cliché declarations to the contrary,
    the Regime's Intelligence is in full collaboration with the CIA, and every so often sends a delegation to Washington to exchange info and receive instructions. This
    was even printed not so long ago in the American Press (IHT).
    H.E.the Ambassador alludes to the Baath decision "to allow a Multiparty System and a margin of Civil Liberties". How generous of Big Brother!
    However, the reality of things belie these affirmations. Independent free thinkers like Dalilah, Binni and others, and lately Michel Kilo are led to the Tadmor monstrosity which is the Regime's image.
    Syria today is nominally governed by the young President who 'inherited' the country (the hight of Socialism!). He may be an Occulist but one wishes he finds a
    remedy to his political Myopia by reining-in his Valkyri sister, her mercenary husband and his brother Maher. But best of all, if he has the subabdominal 'tonsils',
    he shld start radical Reforms before it is too late. Only then will he be remembered by History. Otherwise, he will remain 'Fils à Papa', as the French say,
    a nonentity as he has been todate.

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 5/23/2006 12:38 PM  

  • By Anonymous Anonymous, at 2/06/2007 9:12 AM  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home


 
Site Feed